Agostino has also built a fabulous hockey portfolio in his own right. The only two-time Star Ledger State Player of the Year (2009 and 2010), Agostino closed his stellar career at Delbarton by scoring 50 goals as a senior – four coming in a 7-2 victory over Gloucester Catholic for the NJSIAA Non-Public Championship 2010 – to go with 33 assists for 83 points.
In his four seasons Delbarton posted a 103-7-5 record that included three Private State titles, three consecutive Star Ledger Trophies, four Gordon Conference championships and two Gordon Cup trophies. Agostino is Delbarton’s All-Time leading scorer with 261 career points, surpassing the previous Delbarton record of 242 set by Dale Reinhardt in 2004. Agostino went on to play for four years at Yale, winning an NCAA Championship with the Bulldogs before playing in the NHL with the Calgary Flames, St. Louis Blues and Boston Bruins. Agostino was the 2017 American Hockey League MVP.